“For the Players”. A motto expertly devised at a time where there was uncertainty about the direction the gaming industry was heading in, with talks of DRM, always online and not being able to trade games with your mates doing the rounds. As Microsoft started to inch the blade closer to it’s abdomen with the Xbox One launch, Sony used the motto to propel itself in the graces of its now ever-growing “PlayStation Nation”, another one of its constructs, carrying favour with its denizens. Facing near bankruptcy, Sony went all out to win the favour of its fanbase with impressive success, far beyond what even it anticipated. Since then, it has seemingly stayed true to it’s saying. Until now.

Investors > Gamers

This picture of Jim Ryan isn't without some sense of irony

This picture of Jim Ryan isn’t without some sense of irony

Absolute power corrupts absolutely. As it’s grip on the industry gets tighter day by day, we see chinks in the armour of what now appears to an emperor concerned with the preservation of self above all else. In a way, this was always the case and quite frankly, there is nothing wrong with it to an extent. However, Sony has now adopted a stance that only the most diehard of its followers can defend. Have a gander at Sony’s Jim Ryan and his response to Eurogamer regarding Sony’s refusal to allow cross play with Nintendo and Microsoft:

Unfortunately it’s a commercial discussion between ourselves and other stakeholders

What then followed was an excuse by Ryan about concerns for children only for that to be immediately shut down by the interviewer as he correctly referenced the fact that Nintendo, the most child-conscious of companies was agreeable to cross play.

What is Cross Play and why should you care?

The devs behind rocket league are almost begging Sony to reconsider its stance on cross play

The devs behind rocket league are almost begging Sony to reconsider its stance on cross play

Cross play allows players on all platforms to play together, if the game is available on the respective platform. In an industry where an artificial barrier has existed for far too long save for some exceptions, this would be the biggest moves to bring together a gaming community usually separated by hardware. Have you got mates on COD, Fifa, Titanfall or any online multiplayer game that you can’t play with because they play the same game but on a different platform? This could alleviate the problem so that regardless of platform, you get to play together.

This is the first time we are seeing a push for cross play at such a scale and involving so many platforms. Minecraft is a behemoth in the gaming industry and Rocket League has worked it’s way into the hearts of over 25 million gamers, with that number only set to grow as it makes its debut on the Nintendo Switch console.

Excusing the Emperor

So who on Earth and on what basis would anyone other than Sony, defend the company’s stance here when cross play would obviously benefit gamers? There have been some pretty flimsy excuses doing the rounds and some of these are as follows:

1. It’s because Microsoft wants Sony to Use Xbox Live

Defenders of Sony every time Rocket League is mentioned

Defenders of Sony every time Rocket League is mentioned

False. Just look at Rocket League.  Whilst Microsoft use Xbox Live servers for Minecraft, that shouldn’t really be a surprise considering the fact that it owns the IP! I have seen some ludicrous defenders completely and wilfully ignoring Rocket League as evidence contrary to the assertion that Microsoft mandates use of its own servers cross play titles. Rocket League’s Jeremy Dunham quickly hammered the nail into that argument:

We run our own matchmaking. None of the platforms are aware of what’s going on in the other’s ecosystem. We control all that

2. The PlayStation Player Pool Is “Big Enough”

Cross Play on Titanfall 2 would be a godsend

Cross Play on Titanfall 2 would be a godsend

The PlayStation 4  having the biggest player pool for most games doesnt mean that we don’t need cross play. That’s not the point of cross play; it’s not there just to bolster numbers. Even still, this would benefit PlayStation gamers too as Rocket League’s Dunham stated:

One, you can have faster matchmaking. The bigger the pool, the faster the matchmaking. It benefits everybody. Two, you get better quality opponents. In a bigger pool you have better people who are closer to your location

Take Titanfall 2 as an example of an excellent title but with a relatively small player pool across all platforms, including the PS4. If the title were to have a unified player base with Xbox and PS, this would surely benefit everyone?

you can’t claim to be “for the players” and then shaft them because of concerns for your investors

Regardless of the above, the ability to one day play only with your mates irrespective of the platform you play on is the real benefit of cross play. That’s what this is all about.

3. Why should Sony pander to it’s competitors?

Priority number one

Priority number one

This one really irks me. We’ve all seen people bend over backwards for their favourite corporation in this industry but something that benefits gamers should be encouraged not excused on the basis that the corporations profits would somehow be affected. Even so, how would this negatively impact Sony?

The longer this goes on and the more alienated the Sony fanbase is from the rest of the world, should cross platform games become more commonplace, this would actually serve to harm Sony than benefit it. PlayStation Nation would then be more akin to North Korea but with some visas allowing cross platform play on PC alone.

Besides, you can’t have your cake and eat it; you can’t claim to be “for the players” and then shaft them because of concerns for your investors. Sony’s proclamation will always be subject to scrutiny.

4. “But Microsoft refused this last gen!”

So? Just like Sony is in the wrong now, Microsoft was back then. Are you really telling me that Sony is so vindictive that it won’t play ball because of Microsoft’s stance on cross platform play last gen? This is a shoddy excuse unless you are simply just drawing attention to the fact.

Call to Action

Due to the fact that Sony commands a massive lead in the gaming industry, should they refuse to budge on this stance, I fear that we will lose the opportunity for a fully unified online gaming community.

There are some technical challenges ahead but none of these can really be addressed if Sony continues to reject cross platform gaming with other consoles. Jim Ryan states that the policy is always up for review and therefore, this isn’t set in stone so we should apply pressure on Sony to rectify this. Make your voice heard and please, don’t excuse Sony here. Use the hashtag #PS4Crossplay to make your voices heard. Cross play benefits us all. We have enough borders in the real world for them to also exist in our digital realm.


Do you think Sony are wrong here? Are you one of those who excuses Sony? If so, let us know your thoughts on comments below. No registration necessary.

Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+Share on RedditEmail this to someone
Share this Article

Gaz

Proprietor of www.gameondaily.com and a die-hard gaming fan since I was old enough to hold a controller.

You may also like...

8 Responses

  1. It is interesting that Sony are not participating in this Cross-play. It takes me back to when Sony electronics would always have their own proprietary technologies, like Memory Sticks for instance. Perhaps it is in their company’s DNA to push exclusivity.

    I ultimately don’t think it is a big deal if Sony don’t join in. We haven’t had cross-play so far and there are lots of people playing multiplayer just fine now. Cross-play would certainly be better but it’s not too disappointing.

    I assume Sony has the most to lose with Crossplay. If you take a child who is getting a console, it is more likely that his friends are going to be PS4 owners (based on sales numbers) and to play with his friends, he would have to get a PS4. If Crossplay was across 100% of the titles, he could get an XB1 and still play with his friends…therefore Sony probably have the most to lose should this become popular. We are a long way from this scenario though.

    The idea of allowing kids to play Minecraft together no matter what device they are on sounds like a great idea to me. It’s a shame they are not able to do this (at least yet…firms have gone 180 on some decision in this generation)

    • Gaz says:

      It’s a shame though. We are seeing big strides made now in the x play and arguably the biggest player in the game isn’t playing ball. The more that goes on, the less likely we will ever get to a unified online space.

      In the absence of Sony not doing it, I hope devs at least continue to push x play for Nintendo, Xbox and PC.

  2. Kamille says:

    Of-course it isn’t. SFV’s crossplay is probably the one best thing about that game because it ensures there’s many people to play against. Meanwhile other games like Guilty Gear and King of Fighters are already dead. There are so few people playing online it’s not easy to find one match let alone try looking for a ranked match, it’s practically impossible.

    • Gaz says:

      Absolutely. People pretend the PS player pool is so massive that it doesn’t need cross play. There are several games that will benefit from it.

  3. RedHeat says:

    Did the Phill the Shill right this?

  4. Hicken says:

    “ourselves and other stakeholders” does not even investors.

    Too bad this site is already well-known for being deeply rooted in the Xbox camp.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>